6

Concerning this question: Confusion with que / qui / dont / où

  1. OP asked a question that appeared to be homework.
  2. S/he was told it was unsuitable.
  3. OP vandalized the question.
  4. As close votes are ongoing, another user proposed an un-vandalization, and I approved it.
  5. Laure let the other user know that it was not necessary to un-vandalize the question.

To my way of thinking, the ideal situation for this question is that it has its original form and is closed with the note explaining that such questions appear to be homework problems.

Any other thoughts on how best to deal with situations like this?

  • I'm not sure why this merits a downvote; I'm asking this legitimately in order to understand the best practice or policy because I didn't understand the comment. If the question is flawed, please explain in what way so that I can fix / close / resolve it. Thanks! – Luke Sawczak Apr 10 '17 at 21:26
  • +1 Thanks for allowing clarification. I was the one who had flagged OP's edit in the first place. I thought it would be better deleted. – Laure Apr 11 '17 at 5:47
6

If you see self-vandalism, i.e. a user removing the substance of their question and replacing it with garbage, then please:

  1. Flag it (and explain what's going on in your flag; “self vandalism” is enough);
  2. Revert the vandalism, but only once (if this gets into an edit war, let moderators deal with it). (Exception: if the question is replaced by grossly offensive material, it may be warranted to edit again.)

If you unvandalize a post, please leave a polite comment requesting not to do this. What to say in the comment depends on several factors:

  • For an unanswered question from an unregistered user (it says “unregistered” on their profile page), suggest that they can click the “flag” button underneath the question and request deletion.
  • For an unanswered question from a registered user (it doesn't say “unregistered” on their profile page), suggest that they can delete the question by clicking the “delete” button underneath the question.
  • For an answered question, explain that we don't delete answered questions, because that would take the answers away as well.

The same goes for highly-upvoted answers. For answers that weren't really worth keeping in the first place, just getting the answer to be deleted through normal means (e.g. the low quality queue) is enough.

By the way, many cases of vandalism (including this one are caught by a bot whose main job is to detect spam. This explains why you might see edits to revert vandalism from people who don't normally use the site.

  • 1
    Merci des précisions ! – Luke Sawczak Apr 10 '17 at 23:19

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .